S. Ct. Civ. No. 2012-0018

In a dispute over use of a right of way on commercial property involving four adjacent parcels of land, previously reviewed by this Court in Caribbean Healthways, Inc. v. James, 55 V.I. 691 (V.I. 2011), the injunction entered by the Superior Court on remand from that decision is internally inconsistent and remains broader than necessary to restrain any impermissible conduct with regard to use of trailers longer than 20 feet. Thus the permanent injunction granted is overly broad, and the February 2, 2012 Order is reversed. This case is again remanded to the Superior Court so that it may narrow the scope of the permanent injunction.